A well-crafted senior claims manager job description is your secret weapon for attracting top-tier leaders who can navigate complex claims and mentor your team. Think of it not just as a list of duties, but as your first conversation with a future leader—it needs to clearly communicate the role's strategic value, day-to-day responsibilities, and the qualifications that matter most. It’s both a recruiting magnet and a performance roadmap.

Your Complete Senior Claims Manager Job Description Template

Putting together a compelling job description is arguably the most important first step in hiring. A great post does more than just list tasks; it sells the opportunity and gives candidates a real feel for your company's culture and professionalism.

I've put together this template to be easily adaptable. You can use it to build a senior claims manager job description that truly connects with the experienced professionals you want to hire.

Just copy the template below and replace the bracketed text with your company’s details. Every part of this template is designed to set clear expectations and draw in candidates who have that perfect mix of leadership, technical know-how, and strategic vision.

Understanding the Template Components

Before you dive in, let’s quickly break down why each section is so important. A logical structure helps candidates figure out fast if the role is the right move for them. You want to be direct and informative but also build some excitement about the position and your company.

The following table is a quick cheat sheet for what goes where in your job description. It’ll help you make sure your final post is comprehensive and makes a strong impression.

Key Components of a Senior Claims Manager Job Description

By covering all these bases, you’re not just posting a job—you’re starting a conversation that will attract the seasoned, qualified claims leaders you need.

Breaking Down Core Responsibilities and Daily Duties

When you're writing a senior claims manager job description, you need to be crystal clear about what the job actually entails, both strategically and on a day-to-day basis. This isn't just a role for handling escalated claims; it’s about architecting the entire claims department, from setting policy to mentoring the team. The best managers are masters at juggling high-level strategy with the hands-on realities of claims processing.

You can really break down the role's responsibilities into four key pillars. Think of these as the foundation for a top-tier claims department and a great way to show candidates the full scope of what you expect.

1. Strategic Claims Management

This is all about the big picture. A senior claims manager is responsible for creating and executing the department's strategy so it lines up with the company's larger goals. The mission here is to make the claims team a genuine value-driver, not just a cost center.

• Policy and Procedure Development: You’ll expect them to build, tweak, and document the official claims handling guidelines. This ensures everyone on the team is consistent, compliant, and following best practices.

• Budgetary Oversight: This person will own the department's budget. That means managing everything from settlement reserves and operational expenses to vendor costs, all while keeping a close eye on the bottom line.

• Performance Monitoring: They need to set up and track Key Performance Indicators (KPIs). Think claim cycle times, settlement accuracy, and customer satisfaction scores—the metrics that prove the department is always getting better.

2. Team Leadership and Development

Great senior managers are, first and foremost, great leaders. A huge part of their job is building a claims team that is skilled, engaged, and firing on all cylinders. This goes way beyond simple supervision; it's about active coaching and mapping out career paths for their people.

They are ultimately on the hook for hiring, training, and keeping top talent. This means conducting performance reviews, giving consistent feedback, and spotting the next generation of leaders within the team.

3. Complex Claims Adjudication and Oversight

While they won't be handling every single claim that comes in, senior managers are the final decision-makers on the most complex, high-value, and sensitive cases. Their expertise is absolutely critical when a claim carries significant financial or reputational risk for the company.

For example, their duties include overseeing the tricky total loss appraisal process to guarantee fair and accurate settlements. They also have the final say on large or litigated claims, often working side-by-side with legal counsel.

4. Operational Excellence and Process Improvement

Finally, a core function of this role is to constantly make the claims process better, faster, and more efficient. This means sniffing out bottlenecks, evaluating new technologies, and encouraging a culture where new ideas are welcome.

Senior managers work with IT, data analytics, and other departments to roll out tools and workflows that make life easier for both employees and customers. They are always on the lookout for ways to reduce claim leakage and improve results through smarter, more streamlined processes.

What to Look For: Essential Skills and Qualifications

A top-tier senior claims manager is a unique blend of a technical expert and a genuine leader. When you write your job description, you need to be crystal clear about the non-negotiable hard skills while also painting a picture of the soft skills that make a manager truly exceptional. This is how you attract candidates who can master both the technical details and the human element of the job.

Think of it this way: the right person will have a solid foundation built on education, real-world experience, and professional certifications. These are the table stakes. Their strategic thinking and leadership abilities are what they build on top of that foundation.

Critical Hard Skills and Technical Know-How

Hard skills are the bedrock of the role—the specific, measurable abilities someone needs to get the job done right. For a senior claims manager, these are all about maintaining compliance, ensuring accuracy, and keeping the department running like a well-oiled machine.

• Claims Software Proficiency: You can't manage what you can't see. Candidates absolutely need hands-on experience with major claims management systems. Mentioning platforms like Guidewire or Duck Creek shows you’re serious. This is how they’ll oversee workflows and pull the reports that matter.

• Regulatory Knowledge: A deep, practical understanding of state and federal insurance regulations is non-negotiable. This includes everything about fair claims settlement practices. It's not just about ticking a box; it's about protecting the company from serious legal and financial risk.

• Data Analysis and Reporting: The best managers use data to tell a story. They need the ability to dive into claims data, spot emerging trends, and build reports that actually mean something. This skill is what separates a reactive manager from a proactive, strategic one.

• Financial Acumen: At the end of the day, claims management is a financial function. Your candidate must be comfortable with budgeting, setting accurate reserves, and financial forecasting. These skills are essential for managing the department's financial health and plugging any potential claim leakage.

The Leadership Qualities That Matter Most

While technical skills get a candidate in the door, it's their soft skills that will determine if they can actually lead a team, navigate complex situations, and drive the business forward. These are often the make-or-break qualities that distinguish a good manager from a great one.

In this role, I get to influence recovery outcomes on a scale I never could have reached in traditional patient care. I’m not just helping the patients I see directly. I’m equipping entire teams of clinicians with tools and knowledge that change their patients’ lives. That’s not sales, that’s advocacy!

This is a perfect example of how a leader’s influence goes far beyond just managing their direct reports.

Here are the key soft skills you should be screening for:

• Strategic Thinking: Look for someone who can see beyond the daily grind. They need to connect their department's goals to the company's broader objectives and have a sense of where the industry is heading next.

• Negotiation and Conflict Resolution: This is a huge part of the job. You need someone with proven experience in handling tough negotiations, whether it's with claimants, attorneys, or other third parties. They should be able to de-escalate conflict and find common ground.

• Leadership and Mentorship: A track record of developing people is a must. Ask about how they've coached, mentored, and motivated their teams. A great leader builds a culture where people want to learn, grow, and perform at their best.

Must-Have Licenses and Certifications

Certain licenses and certifications aren't just nice-to-haves; they're proof of a candidate's expertise and commitment to their craft.

1. State-Specific Adjuster Licenses: A valid Property & Casualty (P&C) adjuster license is typically the bare minimum. A candidate who already holds licenses in multiple states—or has the ability to get them quickly—is significantly more valuable.

2. Professional Designations: Designations like the Associate in Claims (AIC) or the highly respected Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter (CPCU) are a clear signal of deep industry knowledge and professionalism. Highlighting these in your senior claims manager job description will help you attract serious, career-minded professionals who have invested in their own development.

Adapting the Job Description for Insurtech and Startups

When you're hiring for an insurtech or a startup, a standard, old-school job description for a senior claims manager just won't cut it. These companies operate on a completely different wavelength, and they need leaders who are more than just managers—they need innovators, builders, and creative problem-solvers. To catch the eye of that kind of talent, your senior claims manager job description needs to talk about technology, agility, and making a real impact.

Forget about focusing on legacy systems and rigid, established procedures. Instead, play up the opportunity to build new processes from scratch. The best candidates for these roles are excited by the challenge of creating and scaling something new, not just maintaining the status quo. They want to see that they’ll have a direct hand in shaping the company's claims function.

Emphasizing Technology and Data Fluency

In the insurtech world, technology is the business, not just a support tool. Your job description has to make this crystal clear by prioritizing skills that might be an afterthought in a more traditional insurance company. A modern claims leader has to be completely at ease in a data-rich environment.

• AI-Driven Claims Processing: Talk about experience with (or at least a genuine excitement for) AI, machine learning, and automated decision-making in claims. Frame it as a chance to work with groundbreaking tools that are changing the industry.

• Data Analytics and Visualization: Don't just ask for "reporting" skills. Be specific about needing someone who can dig into large datasets to spot trends, forecast outcomes, and inform strategy. If they have experience with tools like Tableau or Power BI, that’s a huge bonus.

• Agile Methodologies: Startups thrive on their ability to pivot and adapt. Mentioning experience with Agile or Scrum signals that you get it—you value collaboration, constant improvement, and getting things done quickly.

Highlighting a Builder's Mindset

The people drawn to startups are often builders at heart. They get a buzz from creating something from the ground up and seeing their work directly influence the company’s success. For more ideas on how to find these candidates, check out specialized guides on P&C staffing strategies.

A senior claims manager role at a startup is less about managing an existing system and more about inventing a better one. We look for candidates who get excited by a blank whiteboard and the challenge of turning innovative ideas into a scalable, efficient claims operation.

Use language that speaks directly to this "builder" mentality. Instead of "overseeing claims," try "designing and implementing a tech-first claims workflow." Rather than "managing a team," shift to "building and scaling a high-performance claims team from the ground up." These simple changes in wording send a powerful message: you're looking for a proactive leader who will define the department's future, not just manage its present.

What to Pay a Senior Claims Manager: A Guide to Salary Benchmarks

When you're writing a job description for a senior claims manager, getting the salary right is a critical first step. Compensation for this role isn't a fixed number—it can swing quite a bit depending on your industry, company size, and where you're located. To land the best candidates, you have to know what the market is actually paying.

Relying on just one source for salary data can give you a skewed picture. Different platforms use their own methods and data pools, which leads to a surprisingly wide range of reported salaries. The smartest approach is to triangulate data from several reliable sources to get a true feel for what candidates expect. A solid salary benchmarking strategy ensures your offer is both competitive and fair. To get more in-depth on this, check out our guide on what is salary benchmarking.

Comparing the Top Salary Data Sources

If you look at the numbers for a Senior Claims Manager, you'll see some pretty big differences across the major job sites. This is exactly why looking at multiple benchmarks is so important for figuring out a competitive salary range.

The chart below shows the average salaries from three major platforms. You can see just how much they vary.

As you can see, Salary.com comes in with a much higher average than Indeed or ZipRecruiter, which really drives home the point about not relying on a single number.

A Senior Claims Manager is a crucial hire, and the salary data proves it's a role with a wide pay band. One platform, looking at job postings from the last 36 months, shows an average U.S. salary of $114,453. That figure is 17% higher than another source's reported average of $97,929. On the other hand, a major player like Salary.com puts the average annual salary for a senior-level claims manager at a much higher $165,327. This massive gap—from around $98,000 to over $165,000—often comes down to how these platforms define job titles and seniority. You can dig into some of these findings yourself over on Indeed.com.

What Makes Salaries Vary So Much?

Several key factors can push a candidate's salary expectations to the high or low end of that range. Keeping these in mind will help you put together a more compelling offer.

• Industry and Company Stage: A hot insurtech startup might lean on equity as part of the compensation package, whereas a huge, established insurance carrier will likely offer a more traditional salary and bonus structure.

• Specialized Expertise: A manager who has deep experience in a niche area, like cyber claims or high-stakes litigation, is going to command a premium.

• Geographic Location: It’s no surprise that pay varies wildly between a major city and a smaller town. We’ll get into the specifics of this in the next section.

• Scope of Responsibility: The bigger the team, the more complex the claims, and the larger the budget they oversee, the higher the salary you can expect to pay.

How Geographic Location Impacts Compensation

It’s no secret that where you live impacts your paycheck, but for a senior claims manager, the difference can be massive. This isn't just a state-by-state issue; compensation for this role can swing wildly between cities within the same state. Because of this, relying on national averages alone when putting together an offer is a recipe for failure.

If you're hiring remotely or setting up a new office, you absolutely have to get a handle on these local market differences. An offer that would be a knockout in one city could be a lowball offer just a few hours' drive away. This is why digging into city-specific salary data is crucial.

State and City Level Salary Disparities

Let's look at a real-world example. The average salary for a senior claims manager in California is around $100,757, which seems pretty close to the national average. But that number is misleading because it papers over huge local variances.

Take Los Angeles, for instance. The average salary there skyrockets to $213,016 a year. Some top-end roles can even reach an eye-watering $492,390, which you often see with large insurers handling complex entertainment or liability claims. You can dig into more of these local salary details on sites like ZipRecruiter. This proves that a one-size-fits-all salary just doesn’t work for a role this important.

Getting a firm grasp on geographic pay differences is a cornerstone of smart hiring. It lets you budget realistically for new locations and craft offers that will actually appeal to the best candidates in their home market—whether they're in a major city or working from home somewhere else.

Practical Implications for Your Job Description

When you write your senior claims manager job description, it's smart to address location head-on, especially if the role is remote. Here’s how you can handle it:

• Define Pay Zones: For remote positions, consider creating salary bands based on geographic cost of living. You might have a Tier 1 for expensive cities like New York or San Francisco and a Tier 2 for mid-cost areas.

• Be Upfront: Simply stating that compensation will be adjusted based on location helps set clear expectations from the get-go. This transparency can attract better-qualified candidates who know what to expect.

Taking the time to research salaries by location isn't just about being fair—it's about being competitive. It gives you the edge you need to attract the kind of senior claims leadership that will help your company grow.

Key Interview Questions for Senior Claims Manager Candidates

A strong job description gets people to apply, but asking the right interview questions is how you find your next great leader. Your interview process should be a well-rounded mix of questions that probe a candidate’s technical claims knowledge, their judgment in tricky situations, and their past behaviors. This approach gives you a complete 360-degree view of what they bring to the table.

I’ve put together a list of questions, broken down by category, to help you evaluate every angle of a candidate's background. Each one is crafted to show you not just what they've done, but how they think, lead, and get things done.

Behavioral Interview Questions

Behavioral questions are built on a simple idea: past performance is the best predictor of future behavior. These questions push candidates to give you real-world examples from their careers.

• "Describe a time you had to lead your team through a significant change, such as a new claims system or a major shift in company policy. How did you manage the transition and ensure buy-in?"

  • What to look for: A top-tier answer will walk you through their communication plan, show empathy for their team’s worries, and detail the concrete steps they took to train and support everyone. A red flag is focusing only on the technical side of the change while ignoring the people involved.

• "Tell me about the most complex or high-value claim you've personally overseen. What made it challenging, and what was the outcome?"

  • What to look for: Pay attention to how they deconstruct a complicated problem. Did they collaborate effectively with legal or other experts? Could they make a tough call under pressure? A fantastic answer will also touch on the financial and reputational stakes for the business.

Situational Interview Questions

These questions drop hypothetical scenarios into a candidate's lap to see how they'd navigate them. It’s all about gauging their problem-solving instincts and on-the-spot judgment.

• "Imagine one of your top-performing claims adjusters is consistently failing to meet compliance documentation standards. How would you handle this situation?"

  • What to look for: The ideal response is all about coaching, not punishment. They should talk about digging into the root cause, offering specific training, and setting clear, measurable expectations for improvement before even thinking about disciplinary action.

The point here isn't to trip up the candidate. It's to see their mind at work. A strong senior claims manager can lay out a clear, logical, and people-first plan for tackling tough spots, which speaks volumes about both their expertise and their leadership style.

• "You notice a sudden spike in claim cycle times for a specific type of property claim. What steps would you take to diagnose and resolve the issue?"

  • What to look for: You want to hear a data-driven approach. A great candidate will immediately talk about pulling reports, analyzing the numbers to pinpoint the bottleneck, and then—crucially—talking to the team to get the story behind the data before rolling out a fix.

Technical and Experience-Based Questions

These are the nuts-and-bolts questions. They’re designed to confirm that the technical skills and industry knowledge they listed on their resume are the real deal.

1. "How have you used claims data and analytics to drive strategic decisions or improve departmental KPIs in your previous roles?"

2. "Which claims management software platforms are you most proficient with? Can you provide an example of how you used one to improve workflow efficiency?"

3. "What is your process for managing litigation and liaising with legal counsel on high-exposure claims?"

A Framework for Your Interview Questions

To get the most out of your interview, it helps to be deliberate about what you're asking and why. This table links core competencies for a Senior Claims Manager to specific question types, helping you structure a more insightful conversation.

Interview Question Framework

Using a mix of these questions ensures you get a holistic view of the candidate, moving beyond their resume to understand how they would truly perform and lead within your organization.

Remember, an interview is a two-way street. A truly engaged and strategic candidate will come prepared with their own questions. It's a great sign when they ask insightful strategic questions to ask from an interviewer, as it shows they are thinking critically about the role and the company.

How to Source and Attract Top Claims Talent

A powerful senior claims manager job description is your foundation, but finding the truly exceptional talent requires a much more proactive strategy. You can't just post an opening and hope for the best anymore. The reality is, the best candidates are often passive—they're already employed, performing well, and not actively scrolling through job boards.

To reach them, you have to become a bit of a talent hunter. Professional networks are your prime hunting grounds. A platform like LinkedIn is a goldmine for this, letting you identify experienced managers based on their work history, skills, and industry connections. A few smart, targeted searches can give you a solid list of people who look like a great fit on paper.

Engaging Passive Candidates

Once you've found them, the real work begins. The key to turning a passive candidate into an interested one is a thoughtful, personalized outreach message. Generic, copy-and-paste messages get deleted instantly. Your first impression needs to show you've actually done your homework.

• Reference Their Experience: Mention something specific from their profile that caught your eye, like a project they led or an accomplishment they listed.

• Highlight the Opportunity: Draw a clear line connecting their specific skills to a unique challenge or growth opportunity your role offers.

• Keep It Concise: They're busy. Get straight to the point in a brief, direct message that makes it obvious why you're contacting them specifically.

A great outreach message doesn't just ask for a resume; it starts a conversation. It might say something like, "I saw your work leading the claims team at [Previous Company] and was really impressed. We're building a tech-forward claims department and could use that kind of expertise."

This personalized approach shows genuine interest and respect, making your opportunity stand out from the noise. Refining how you find talent is an ongoing effort, and you can learn more valuable techniques by exploring resources on insurance agency recruiting. When you combine a strong job description with a smart sourcing plan, you stop passively waiting for applicants and start actively building the world-class claims team you need.

Tired of the endless search for top-tier talent? Job Compass combines AI speed with expert human vetting to deliver a shortlist of 1-3 perfectly matched, pre-screened candidates in just 48 hours. Stop sifting through resumes and start interviewing the best. Find your next great hire faster at https://jobcompass.ai.